[SOLVED] Ported from F9 to VOIP.MS outgoing OK - no incoming.
azrobert:
Quote from: Taoman on May 04, 2021, 05:29:15 pm
So I got motivated. I probably tried adding my OB110 about 50 times with no luck.
Can you do a test for me? There was a disagreement on whether you can make a call over OBiTalk to another device when one or both are not on the dashboard. Neither of us wanted to remove a device from the dashboard to test this. Can you call the OBi202 from the OBi110 and then the reverse. I know you can call the echo test without being registered. Thanks!
Edit:
I think the call will fail.
Taoman:
Quote from: azrobert on May 05, 2021, 01:15:15 pm
Can you call the OBi202 from the OBi110 and then the reverse. I know you can call the echo test without being registered. Thanks!
Edit:
I think the call will fail.
I would have never guessed this considering my OBi110 cannot be added to the OBi dashboard but.......... OBi to OBi calls worked just fine in both directions. Don't OBi to OBi calls require OBiTALK? How would my OBi110 be using OBiTALK when it's not even registered with the OBi portal? Must be communicating directly with the OBiTALK servers I guess.
Edit: Of course I had to do the next logical test:
I removed the OBi202 from the OBi dashboard and tried OBi to OBi calls again with the 110. Again, calls worked fine in both directions even though neither of them were registered on the OBiTALK dashboard.
SteveInWA:
Quote from: Taoman on May 05, 2021, 02:12:53 pm
Quote from: azrobert on May 05, 2021, 01:15:15 pm
Can you call the OBi202 from the OBi110 and then the reverse. I know you can call the echo test without being registered. Thanks!
Edit:
I think the call will fail.
I would have never guessed this considering my OBi110 cannot be added to the OBi dashboard but.......... OBi to OBi calls worked just fine in both directions. Don't OBi to OBi calls require OBiTALK? How would my OBi110 be using OBiTALK when it's not even registered with the OBi portal? Must be communicating directly with the OBiTALK servers I guess.
Color me confused. Now I'm trying to consider what this implies........
Actually, OBiTALK devices, right out of the box, can call to other OBiTALK devices, and can receive calls from other OBiTALK devices, without being registered on a portal account. After all, they can call the OBi echo test number. It's baked into the firmware (the device registers to the OBiTALK network as soon as it gets an IP address).
It's been a while since I tried it, so I tested these scenarios today:
Call from an unregistered OBi 110 to other OBiTALK devices, regardless of the other device's registration status:
works.Calling to an unregistered OBi 110 from a registered or unregistered OBi 200/202/2182: works.Add an unregistered OBi 200 to the OBiTALK dashboard: works.Add an unregistered OBi 110 to the OBiTALK dashboard: fails
azrobert:
Thanks Taoman!
I‘ve been proven wrong and drgeoff was correct. Many many many years ago I deleted my OBi110 from OBiTalk because of problems. I tried calling another device and the call failed. I added the OBi110 back to OBiTalk and calls started working again. Either my test was faulty or the firmware has changed.
Navigation
[0] Message Index
[*] Previous page