jesseasi,
Is your second OBi actually added to your account? This would have been done using the **5 method the same as for your first OBi. Does the second OBi appear on your OBi Dashboard? Can you dial **9222222222 and reach the OBi echo test from the second OBi?
If you make the changes as recommended, then the OBi should reboot itself each time you press the "submit" button. Making changes:
Make changes via the OBi Expert Configuration pages. From your OBi Dashboard, click on your OBi number and follow the prompts to get there. To change a value uncheck both boxes to the right of the value and leave them unchecked. After changing the values on one page, press submit at the bottom of the page and wait a few minutes for the OBi to reboot. Then move on to another page if required.